A Culture of Imbeciles

by July 19, 2014

Guy Debord, author of The Society of the Spectacle, once remarked, "There are two parallel counterrevolutionary confusionist tactics: the partial cooption of new values, and a deliberately anticultural industrially facilitated production, the latter being a natural continuation of the imbecilization of young people begun in their schools and families. We have arrived at a stage of ideological absence in which advertising has become the only active factor, overriding any preexisting critical judgment or transforming such judgment into a mere conditioned reflex."

I thought of this remark when reading that 350.org -- the pied piper of pious poseurs -- is promoting a climate change march in New York City on September 21st. Parade of imbeciles would be a better description.

Four plus decades later, Debord's 1967 treatise Society of the Spectacle remains one of the most profound analyses of modern humanity. Oblivious to the deepening separation of industrial civilization from reality, even scholars of ongoing social disintegration rarely mention Debord's penetrating insights and ideas. As another generation of state-educated children lose the capacity to think for themselves, keeping the intellectual fires burning remains a formidable task.

Producing fantasy in Hollywood and Washington is by now such a prescribed art, that the psychological warfare conducted 24/7 against the minds of all Americans has become child's play. Few even question their fantasies as such. NGOs like 350.org tap into these fantasies about political power, perpetuate and capitalize on them. Pooh-Bahs of the non-profit industrial complex, like McKibben, become their Messiahs.

Absent coherent analysis based on research, social networks become part of the spectacle. As political researchers know, little of progressive activism is based on research and analysis, and much is based on preconceptions or what is fundable. As any astute observer can see, dependence limits strategies.

Debord's remarks on the early development of a culture of imbeciles illustrate that revolutions like the one led by 350.org become exercises in silliness. The fact that media brain-damaged Americans are incapable of withdrawing themselves from the spectacle's spell, is cause for considerable worry.

Allowing oneself to be herded from panicked horror to panicked horror does nothing to end the cycle of destruction; for that one needs to keep one's cool, and to devise means of disrupting the seamless spectacle that shadows us through our daily lives. Only then, can the awakening begin.

  • MJMcEvoy
    July 19, 2014 at 7:52 pm

    Like so many "movements" that have come before them, the new ones seek change without changing.
    Anglocentric Culture sees true movements as a threat, mimics them and then absorbs them, much in the manner that the Constantinian-shift abosrbed the early church. The Beats died once Maynard G. Krebs walked on the TV in Dobbie Gillis; the Hippies died once J.C. Penny's and Sears sold tie-dyes; Hip-Hop was emasculated when Snap, Crakle and Pop danced across the countertop to a hip rendition of their theme song.
    Marching is not the answer, changing your lifestyle and way of thinking, acting and treating others is. But that requires sacrifice on the part of those who demand a sacrifice of the "other."


  • Jay Taber
    July 20, 2014 at 9:53 am

    While these charades might seem harmless to naive consumers of the non-profit spectacle, they unfortunately interfere with the ability of authentic activists and indigenous governing authorities to successfully challenge Wall Street and the modern states it has corrupted. When PR puppets — indigenous or otherwise — dominate social media, both the infantile and the skeptical are led astray.

    Chutzpah personified would be Naomi Klein — board member of 350 dot org — talking about Big Green opportunism. I guess that’s why elites like Rockefeller fund it.

    As for scams, it’s hard to imagine a more losing strategy than the 350 dot org fossil fuel divestment campaign. I mean, shifting university shares in oil companies to Wall Street is hardly going to improve corporate behavior.


Leave a Response