X

Canada’s Broken Human Rights Record

By John Ahni Schertow

It has been said that the true measure of a nation is not found in its technological prowess, in its resource wealth or its military capability; but in the way it treats its disabled, its impoverished and disadvantaged, its women and children, and everyone else that may fall outside of the majority demographic.

Thanks to the United Nations, we can see just how Canada measures up to these terms.

Last week a total of 68 governments went on record against Canada’s deplorable human rights and indigenous rights record as part of the United Nations Human Rights Council’s Universal Periodic Review (UPR).

“The United Kingdom, for example, recommended that Canada give its ‘highest priority’ to addressing ‘fundamental inequalities’ between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people including through ‘resolution of land claims and reconciliation of governance and self-government,'” while “The governments of Norway and Denmark called on Canada to reconsider its opposition to the 2007 UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples,” notes a joint public statement by Quebec Native Women, KAIROS, Inuit Circumpolar Council (Canada), Canadian Friends Service Committee, Amnesty International Canada and others.

Many States also urged Canada to adopt a national plan of action to end the high level of violence, discrimination, and marginalization experienced by Indigenous women.

Some of the other issues raised included:

  • Ratifying UN human rights treaties and complaints mechanisms dealing with torture prevention; persons with disabilities; economic, social and cultural rights; migrant workers; and enforced disappearances.
  • Ensuring the timely and just resolution of outstanding Indigenous land and Treaty disputes;
  • Scrutinizing the use of tasers;
  • Reinstating Canada’s policy of consistently seeking clemency for Canadians sentenced to death in other countries.
  • Adopting measures to protect the rights of migrant workers, including live-in domestic caregivers; and to better safeguard the rights of victims of trafficking.
  • Taking measures to ensure there is no racial, ethnic or religious profiling in Canada’s national security practices;
  • Reforming Canadian law to conform to the absolute ban on deporting individuals to face a serious risk of torture; and
  • Substantially increasing social assistance rates to ensure access to food, housing and other requirements.

“Canada has not yet indicated which recommendations it will accept and which it will reject. The government has just over four months to establish a credible process to reach decisions as to which ones it will take on board. Indigenous Peoples, representative organizations, nongovernmental groups and other levels of government must be brought into those considerations,” notes a press release by Amnesty International.

“As a first step, a meeting of federal, provincial and territorial Ministers responsible for human rights should be convened on an urgent basis to review and respond to these recent UN recommendations. Indigenous Peoples, representative organizations and nongovernmental organizations should play a meaningful role in such a meeting,” says Alex Neve, the Secretary General of Amnesty International Canada.

“Ministers have not met to discuss human rights in Canada since 1988. That failure of attention to human rights is unacceptable. Such a meeting is long overdue, and today’s recommendations from Geneva should set the agenda.”

Video recordings of the session and related documents can be found online at: http://www.un.org/webcast/unhrc/archive.asp?go=090203.