News

Ngobe: We are desperate and abandoned

By • Apr 11, 2008

Earlier this month, the Ngobe of western Panama wrote an urgent appeal that asks the international community for immediate assistance. For some time now they’ve been struggling to stop the US-based company AES from building the Changuinola dam on their traditional lands.

In recent months, the situation has become hopeless for the Ngobe. According to the appeal, the National Police have taken over their community and they are “being subjected to cruel violations of our fundamental human rights.” On top of that, the government has un-communicated them from the world; and they are quite literally being forced to sign away their lands, rights, and livelihoods — “under threat of arms and death.”

Meanwhile, according to Cultural Survival’s latest newsletter, AES has started using lights to work on the Changuinola dam around the clock.

The Ngobe say, “We are desperate and abandoned. The government reiterates that we have no rights, and that they have the power to do as they wish… We ask, please do all in your power to stop this barbarism. Our lives and land depend on being able to stop these violations.”

Cultural Survival has set up two things you can do:

1. Send a letter to persuade Panama’s environmental agency, ANAM, which commissioned AES-Changuinola to build the dam, to halt construction and set up a process that guarantees that the Ngobe peoples’ human rights, now and in the future, are respected.

2. Sign a petition which makes a similar plea to ANAM

3. Global Response also put together a list of contacts for AES. Feel free to write them too.

Photo by ACDPanama

Letter of the Ngobe People affected by Dam Chan 75 of the Company AES Changuinola

We send this letter as an urgent plea for international support and help. The Ngäbe located in the community of Charco La Pava, District of Changuinola, Province of Bocas del Toro, Republic of Panama, are being subjected to cruel violations of our fundamental human rights. The community has been taken over by the national police, whom have proceeded to repeatedly use deadly force against us, torturing community leaders, abusing us through physical and verbal agressions, destroying our property, land and homes, and controlling through violence all aspects of our daily life.

The Company AES Changuinola, which wishes to develop a Hydro-electric plant in the Changuinola River, the contractor company of swedish origins CCW (Changuinola Civil Works), in complicity with the governor of the Province of Bocas del Toro, Esther Mena Chiu, of the Mayor Virginia Abrego, regional ANAM representative Valentin Pineda, have all participated directly in the violation of our human rights, dignity and humanity. AES Changuinola personnel involved are area responsible Engineer Thais Mejia, as well as Rodolfo Ayarza, Beanvides Morales y Lidami Morales. The National Police has worked through the National Police Unit, Zone 9 of Changuinola, under the orders of Jose Maneul Rios.

Among the examples of human rights violations: the National Police through a Riot Control Unit beat, threatened and dragged children, pregnant women and elderly people of the community, publicly stripped nude Ana Castillo, and then dragged and beat her through the streets, threatened Francisco Santos with death, forced community members with armed guards to sign documents whose content they did not know, set fire to the house of Isabel Becker and caused deadly injuries to the boy Ivan Miranda due to a police baton blow to the face.

The Company AES Changuinola together with the National Government, and under the armed vigilence of police officers, imposed two alternatives: accept 2 thousand dollars as payment for each hectare of land (which equals to 20 cents per square meter), or be evicted by force on the first week of April of 2008. We are being forced to negotiate under threat of arms and death.

We are desperate and abandoned. The government reiterates that we have no rights, and that they have the power to do as they wish.

They have us uncommunicated and dont let anyone visit the community. They have tortured, evicted and threatened to death our leaders, have destroyed our lands, forests and animals which are the source of food for our people. We live in constant fear because there is no law that protects us in these places.

We ask, please do all in your power to stop this barbarism. Our lives and land depend on being able to stop these violations.

Ernesto Lopez

Ngöbes Communities affected by the construction of the Hydro-electric plants. we extracted this information from the declarations made by Ana Castillo done on the 9th of March of 2008.

1 Mrs Castillo and her sons, 12 year old Anselmo Santos, 10 year old Didier Santos and 6 year old Irene Santos, went where most of the communisty was protecting itself from the explotions, when they were violently supressed, as Mrs Castillo narrates: “my kids and I went to where the others were at the entrance to the community asking the AES employees to please not to harm their crops, when by orders of Engineers Rodolfo Ayarza and Lidami Morales, the police hit and kicked me, they grabbed me by my hairs, they hit my children with their baton, I only wanted them not to harm my crops”.

2 “When I was on the floor the police stepped on my chest with his boot while he laughed”.

3 “One police officer grabbed my clothes and laughing tore it off, he stripped me naked publicly, and dragged me naked to the police quarters. Everybody saw me naked and I felt embarassed”.

4 Mrs. Ana Castillo was verbally abused, stripped nude, beaten and exposed to the public by the National Police Units, Zone 9 of the Changuinola Police headquarters, under the order of police chief Jose Manuel Rios. Once detained in the Police quarters, Mrs. Castillo was again verbally abused, threatened and admonished by the police units, and as she narrates: “in the police quarters I wanted water, and cried together with my children. The police told me: you are stupid and rude..what rights are you going to demand? You have no rights, next time we will take everything by force. You want water? Then he laughed and hit me and didnt give me water, when I spoke I was beaten, and told me I had to sign”.

5 The minors, 12 year old Anselmo Santos, 10 year old Didier Santos and 6 year old Irene Santos, whom accompanied their mother, were detained and beaten next to their mother by the National Police. “the police in the quarter would ask my child if he wanted to eat and would then laugh, indians like you have no rights”.

6 “I dont want to see the police, I live here, all our forefathers lived here, if they take me out of here I dont know where I´ll live, I only have this land, when I bathe in the river the police look at me, I want them to leave”.


  • John Ahni SchertowJohn Ahniwanika Schertow is an indigenous rights activist of Mohawk (Kanienkehaka) and mixed-European descent. For the past 8 years, he has served as the e... read full bio

12 thoughts on “Ngobe: We are desperate and abandoned

  1. Ahni

    Hey Max. That looks to be a letter from AES, which seems to glorify the relocation of these families as “the single greatest thing that’s ever happened to their meager lives.”

    In light of AES’s treachery and manipulation of the people, I don’t trust a word of it.

    Reply
  2. Max Harrison

    Really? Thanks a lot!!! I feel a lil confused, because in that blog i read some articles AGAINST AES, so, i dont know if this in particular was true…

    Thanks a lot!!!

    CS

    Reply
  3. Joe Simmons

    We need to get our facts straight, since this matter has some very contradicting issues and we don’t know exactly what’s really happening. There are a lot of conflict of interests on that subject

    Reply
  4. Marc Cisneros

    AES Panama has also created the Emberá-Wounaan Legends and Traditions Story Project, capturing the living lore of this indigenous tribe. The ancient stories touch upon many of AES’s core values, such as the importance of integrity and taking care of the environment. The series of stories was launched in 2006, in coordination with AES Corporation’s 25th Anniversary.

    Reply
  5. Ahni

    I think the facts are all pretty straight forward—-the contradiction though, I believe, is coming from the torrent of propaganda that essentially “pulls the blinders” over Indigenous Rights.

    In a nutshell, this is where everyone stands: AES likes to put on a show and talk about how great they are and how much they care about Indigenous People… but they refuse to acknowledge the many Naso and Ngobe who do not want development on their land, and who just want to live their own way of life without any outside interference.

    The govenrment, on the other hand, seems to be posturing itself similar to Peru, who couldn’t care less about indigenous people or their cultures.

    Lastly, the indigenous people themselves: It’s true that some Naso and Ngobe support the projects and wouldn’t mind the perks that AES offers. However, the rest are desperately afraid of losing their land, livelihood and their history – and because they are not being given a say in the matter.

    I’ve posted a few more recent articles that explores the latter a bit further:

    http://intercontinentalcry.org/police-demolish-indigenous-naso-village-help-requested/

    http://intercontinentalcry.org/major-victory-for-the-ngobe-of-western-panama/

    Reply
  6. Andrea Aviles

    I think the panamanian government will continue to make its best efforts to protect the human rights of the indigenous people to live with dignity, to have access to health, housing and education.

    Panama is one of the countries in the region with the most progressive legislations in this matter, since it recognizes the autonomy and other Rights of the indigenous people.

    Reply
  7. Windtalker

    What the hey!!i thought this was sorted? out no wonder Panama has been hit with earthquakes will check into this.

    Reply
  8. Rolando Restrepo

    So nice of you Windtalker … = (

    On the news I saw that Panama’s asking the Human Rights Interamerican Comission to revoke their decision. A Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ statement informed that Panama can’t comply with their requirements since their taking to consideration information that’s more than a year old.

    Reply
  9. dragonfly2

    Protecting the rights of the people? You can’t possibly be serious.

    No authority drags people through the streets naked, forces them to sign away their rights, witholds food water and shelter and doesn’t give them a say in what goes on in their lives if they are protecting their rights.

    This is disgusting, despicable, unconscionable, and repugnant! These people deserve to live in peace, to raise their families and live as they see fit.

    Leave them alone you cowardly bullying pirates!

    Reply
  10. dragonfly2

    Where is the UN? Oh, that’s right, I forgot, they really don’t give a damn about human rights either.

    May Heaven help us. How long, o Lord? How long will you allow evil to continue? We wait upon your promise to ‘destroy those who destroy the earth’.

    Please come soon.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Connect with us

Get our latest articles by email!


It is instructive to see how mental, spiritual and physical health coincide in the indigenous philosophy, while the progressive view remains trapped in a treatment rather than preventive mode. It...
Kia ora, I would like to say unless they, ( those who say no more Full- Blooded Maori), know the whakapapa of every single Maori in Aotearoa, they should just...
Mohawk??I stand and prepared to back my people at any and all cost...
I have worked with, lived with, and been around Copala Triquis for the past 12 years, and have researched extensively the political oppression in teh region - ever since the...
Thank you for your comment, trog69. You might have seen my update http://intercontinentalcry.org/wall-street-tea-party-convergence-19421/ on the story, including a link to a special report by Charles Tanner, titled Take these Tribes Down....
Good afternoon, Mr. Taber. I must admit that part of my astonishment upon reading about this is my complete ignorance that there is a concerted effort to take the rest...
Thank you, David. While it's good that some elected officials are joining environmentalists and tribes in opposing Gateway Pacific Terminal, the Tea Party, AFL-CIO and anti-Indian property rights activists have...
Seattle Mayor Mike McGinn comments on proposed coal trains and export terminals: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOi4iEsSl_k...
Who are the Ngobe
BoqueteThe Ngobe People (also spelled Ngäbe or Ngöbe) can be found primarily in the Ngäbe-Buglé comarca in the Western Panamanian provinces of Veraguas, Chiriquí and Bocas del Toro, as well as in the indigenous town of...
Learn more about the and other Indigenous Peoples around the world

"In a media landscape made up of lies, flash, giant blind spots and corporatized sites of distraction, Intercontinental Cry is a trustworthy pathway to the truth where people who are committed to understanding Indigenous realities can gain insight and information to illuminate and activate their struggles."

Taiaiake Alfred
Professor of Indigenous Governance at UVIC and author of Wasáse
Hair of the Dog